Subscriber

Elaine Loughlin: Ex-partners’ bad blood gives campaign a bit of bite

Election 2024: A wily tit-for-tat has kept the attention on Micheál Martin and Simon Harris at the expense of Sinn Féin
Elaine Loughlin: Ex-partners’ bad blood gives campaign a bit of bite

Outgoing Tánaiste Micheál Martin and Taoiseach Simon Harris could be setting themselves up for some very heavy lifting during possible government formation talks. File picture: Gareth Chaney/PA

A spat a day has bagged plenty of coverage for both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, with the phoney war dominating discussions though the first week of what was promised to be a short, sharp campaign but which has so far been pretty lacklustre.

While it’s unlikely that the parties had a premeditated and agreed plan to launch attacks followed by counter claims against policies and promises, it very much suits both sides.

Unlike the last election, and indeed much of the political discourse since the 2020 poll, Sinn Féin has not been the target of criticisms coming from Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael in recent days.

Whether in the Dáil, through press releases, or at media conferences, Sinn Féin feels comfortable being under political attack.

Mary Lou McDonald has at times almost relished the opportunity to remind Simon Harris or Micheál Martin that hitting out at Sinn Féin represents a meek attempt to divert attention away from Government failures.

“If I was to listen to the Coalition parties, I wouldn’t get up out of bed in the morning,” McDonald said this week. 

“They can’t pass a microphone without stating how appalled they are, and how they will never ever, ever speak to Sinn Féin.”

“A lot of people” vote for her party, she added.

For both parties, at least over the first third of this election campaign, speaking about Sinn Féin has not been the main focus.

Elections are notorious for throwing up controversies and this campaign got off to a juicy enough start when Michael O’Leary offended every teacher in the country

But what sparked the most anger was the reaction to the airline boss’s comments by the group of Fine Gael supporters attending an event to launch the election campaign of Enterprise Minister Peter Burke.

Martin only fuelled the fury in staffrooms when he pointed out that the laughter and whooping speaks to an “ethos” in Fine Gael that is at odds with his party which “celebrates the role of teachers”.

But the jibes didn’t stop there.

Tit-for-tat

Launching his party’s manifesto on Monday, Martin said he was a little perplexed to read Fine Gael proposals to charge international protection applicants for accommodation and other supports, as this measure had already been discussed by the outgoing coalition.

On the other side, members of Fine Gael were quick to hit out at plans to decriminalise drugs put forward by Fianna Fáil.

“Astonished to see @fiannafailparty commit to decriminalise personal possession of ALL drugs in their manifesto today,” Senator Barry Ward exclaimed on social media platform X.

Fianna Fáil later clarified that the measure would relate to cannabis and not stronger drugs such as cocaine or heroin.

But it didn’t stop the Taoiseach from entering the argument and he made it clear that his party would not support the proposal as there are “real health dangers in relation to cannabis”.

Later in the day, the Tánaiste accused Justice Minister Helen McEntee of not reading Fianna Fáil’s manifesto after she described it as “back-of-the-matchbox” style politics.

“I would just say to people in Fine Gael headquarters, they need to calm down somewhat,” he added.

McEntee had said Fianna Fáil’s pre-election document contained “little substance” and that it could “scupper the economic progress that we have made in recent years”.

It was a theme picked up on by Fine Gael minister Paschal Donohoe who released a statement on Tuesday criticising Fianna Fáil’s manifesto as leaving “a lot to be desired”.

On Virgin Media’s Tonight Show, Fianna Fáil minister Jack Chambers and Fine Gael’s Hildegarde Naughton called each other “disingenuous” in a debate on policy proposals.

On and on went the bickering.

Fine Gael’s proposal to introduce an 11% Vat rate for food-related businesses was criticised by Fianna Fáil as “regressive”, with claims that it would mean the tax on energy would have to increase.

There were also swipes exchanged between Fianna Fáil’s justice spokesman Jim O’Callaghan and McEntee.

By Thursday, while the media was growing fatigued by tiresome squabbles, the Taoiseach was in no mood for negotiating an election ceasefire that had been proposed by the Tánaiste.

“I don’t like the language that’s been used around ceasefire and the likes,” said Harris. “I mean, there’s a political election going on here in Ireland.

“We’re having a debate around ideas and policies. I hope we’re having a respectful debate.

We launched a plan for small businesses; I don’t think we were out of the room before there were people in Fianna Fáil doing off-the-record briefings in relation to that. 

But both parties should tread carefully.

If the two civil war parties are to share power for another term, agreement will have to be reached on a new department for infrastructure, which Fine Gael have proposed, but Fianna Fáil is against. Instead, Martin’s party is pushing for a new Department of Domestic Affairs.

Fianna Fáil want to retain the 9% Vat rate on energy bills, while Fine Gael believe it should increase to 11% with measures to offset this.

Then of course there will be the dilemma of how to spend the €14bn from the Apple tax case.

Harris has said his party would look to use “at least €10bn” of back taxes from Apple “to help build the homes we need”.

However, Fianna Fáil want to spend the windfall across the electricity grid, water infrastructure, transport, and health digitalisation, as well as housing.

All of these issues, and more, will have to be negotiated before the horse-trading over ministerial portfolios and a rotating taoiseach begins.

Harris and Martin could be setting themselves up for some very heavy lifting during possible government formation talks if they are to overcome the numerous rifts that have emerged between both parties.

Read More

Sinn Féin claim 'sham rows' show 'pretend difference' between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael
Coalition flashpoints emerge as 22-day election campaign kicks off 

more articles

Silhouetted wind turbine at a rural windfarm. European gas prices slip amid forecast for mild, windy weather
Coronavirus Cork woman suspected of accessing thousands of accounts in fraud investigation
Man installing thermal roof insulation layer - using mineral wool panels. Attic renovation and insulation concept Party manifestos leave renters — 20% of households — out of energy efficiency schemes

More in this section

Harlem's hoarders Collyer Brothers S Terry Prone: Hoarding’s hidden issues begin to emerge from the background
Gareth O'Callaghan: Nothing has changed politically in 50 years Gareth O'Callaghan: Nothing has changed politically in 50 years
British-Irish Council - Edinburgh S Elaine Loughlin: Simon Harris must choose his own piece on ministerial chessboard carefully
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited